In April 1862, Union and Confederate forces clashed at Shiloh Church in Tennessee over two days, producing 23,000 casualties and the most shocking display of industrial-scale violence the country had yet seen. This episode covers the events leading up to Shiloh, the battle itself, and why the carnage forced the entire country to reckon with how long and how costly the Civil War would become.

Key Takeaways

• The Union victory at Fort Donelson in February 1862 opened the Tennessee River as a major invasion route into the Confederate interior and put Grant on Lincoln's radar.

• The first naval battle between iron-plated warships, the Monitor and the Virginia (formerly the Merrimack), took place at Hampton Roads in March 1862, just weeks before Shiloh.

• Confederate General Albert Sidney Johnston was killed on the first day of battle at Shiloh, making him the highest-ranking officer on either side to die in combat during the entire war.

• The Union division that helped turn the tide on the second day was led by Brigadier General Lew Wallace, who later wrote the novel Ben-Hur.

• William Tecumseh Sherman, one of Grant's corps commanders at Shiloh, described scenes of piles of dead soldiers and mangled bodies that 'would have cured anybody of war.'

Sign up here to be the first to know about new History250 releases, content & resources!

Questions & Answers (FAQ):

Q1: Who won the Battle of Shiloh?

The Union won, though at enormous cost. After the Confederate surprise attack on April 6th pushed Union forces back toward the Tennessee River, Buell's reinforcements arrived overnight. Grant's combined forces launched a counterattack on April 7th that drove Beauregard's Confederates back to Corinth, Mississippi. The Union held the battlefield and retained control of the Tennessee River corridor.

Q2: Why was Shiloh considered a turning point in the Civil War?

Shiloh's 23,000 casualties in two days shattered any remaining illusion that the war would be short or limited in its violence. Before Shiloh, many Americans on both sides still imagined a relatively contained conflict. After Shiloh, it was clear that both governments were committed to a total war that would demand enormous sacrifices. The scale of killing at Shiloh also elevated Grant's profile and shaped his understanding of what it would take to win.

Q3: What was the significance of General Johnston's death at Shiloh?

Albert Sidney Johnston was the Confederacy's top-ranked general in the field and one of Jefferson Davis's most trusted commanders. His death on the first day of battle left Beauregard in command at a critical moment. Many historians believe Johnston's death robbed the Confederacy of its best chance to crush Grant's army before Buell's reinforcements arrived, though that remains debated.

Q4: Why was the battle fought at Shiloh specifically?

Grant's army was encamped at Pittsburgh Landing near Shiloh Church on the Tennessee River, using it as a staging point for a planned advance on the Confederate rail junction at Corinth, Mississippi. Johnston chose to strike Grant there before Buell could reinforce him. The terrain, woodland cut by ravines running toward the river, shaped the fighting significantly throughout both days.

Q5: How did the Trent Affair nearly bring Britain into the Civil War?

In November 1861, the U.S. warship San Jacinto stopped a British mail ship, the Trent, and seized two Confederate diplomats aboard. Britain was outraged. Prime Minister Palmerston ordered troops to Canada and strengthened the Royal Navy's Atlantic presence. Lincoln defused the crisis by releasing the diplomats, avoiding a formal apology while preventing a confrontation with Britain that could have dramatically changed the war's outcome.

After Manassas: The Union Needs a Win

The Confederate win at Manassas in July of 1861 gave Americans their first great indication that the Civil War would not be short-lived. But the Battle of Shiloh in April 1862 was the first terrible sign of how costly the war would be.

On April 7th, as the battle came to an end, the casualties were counted. More than 23,000 soldiers were killed or wounded, making Shiloh the bloodiest battle up to that point in American history. After the Confederate victory at Manassas, northern morale was low. The Union needed a win. It came off the coast of North Carolina in the Battle of Hatteras Inlet Batteries in late August 1861. Union naval gunboats bombarded the fort there. Then joint Union Army troops and Marines landed to secure the shore. The Union now held control of the North Carolina Sounds, which allowed them to block Southern trade and establish a vital base for further operations. In October 1861, the North suffered another bad loss in Virginia, this time at the Battle of Ball's Bluff near Leesburg in Loudoun County, about 25 miles north of Manassas. Nearly half of the Union soldiers were killed, including Colonel Edward Baker, a former congressman from Illinois and senator from Oregon. Baker was an old friend of Abraham Lincoln's. The war had opened a year earlier with the events covered in our episode on the First Battle of Bull Run.

Grant's Rising Star

The loss at Ball's Bluff prompted Congress to create the Joint Committee on the Conduct of the War, a task force of seven congressmen focused on investigating northern failures and seeking more aggressive tactics. Lincoln resisted the committee's pressure and kept McClellan in command for the time being. The Civil War nearly took an international turn in November 1861. The U.S. warship the San Jacinto seized Confederate diplomats from a British ship, the Trent. Northerners cheered. British Prime Minister Lord Palmerston was outraged.

Lincoln diffused the crisis by releasing the diplomats. The pendulum swung back in the North's direction when on February 6th, 1862, Brigadier General Ulysses S. Grant and his army captured Fort Henry near the border between Tennessee and Kentucky. That opened up the Tennessee River as a major invasion route into the Confederate South. One week later, Grant led another victory at the Battle of Fort Donelson, forcing the Confederates to retreat from much of Kentucky and Tennessee. Grant had now caught the president's attention and earned the praise of the public in the North. His star was rising. On March 7th and 8th, 1862, Missouri was secured for the Union in the Battle of Pea Ridge. On March 8th and 9th, in the naval Battle of Hampton Roads, two armored warships, the USS Monitor and the CSS Virginia, fought each other in combat, the first battle of its kind in history. That same month, Union forces seized the South's largest city, as we cover in our episode on the Union capture of New Orleans.

The Battle of Shiloh

The spring of 1862 brought the war's deadliest battle to date. The Battle of Shiloh was fought on April 6th and 7th, 1862, near Shiloh Church and Pittsburgh Landing on the Tennessee River in southwestern Tennessee. Altogether, there were about 62,000 Union forces and 42,000 Confederates who fought those two days. Grant led the Union forces in the Army of the Tennessee. One of his commanders was William Tecumseh Sherman. Albert Sidney Johnston commanded the Confederate Army of the Mississippi. His second in command was P.G.T. Beauregard. Confederate forces planned to hit Grant's army before the Army of Major General Don Carlos Buell and the Army of the Ohio could arrive.

On April 6th, under the cover of early morning fog, the Confederates launched a surprise attack, initially pushing Union forces back toward the Tennessee River. Johnston was killed on the first day, so Beauregard took command. Buell and the Army of the Ohio arrived overnight to reinforce the Union side. On April 7th, Grant's army launched an attack at 6:00 a.m. From the Tennessee River, the USS Tyler and USS Lexington provided naval artillery in support of Grant's left flank. Twice, Beauregard ordered counterattacks, temporarily stopping the Union advance. A Union division led by Brigadier General Lew Wallace, the future author of Ben-Hur, joined the fighting. By late afternoon, Beauregard realized he was outnumbered and, having already suffered tremendous casualties, retreated toward Corinth.

The Terrible Cost

When the smoke cleared from Shiloh, an estimated 23,000 soldiers had been killed or wounded, by far the costliest battle up to that point in the war. The casualties were about equally distributed between North and South.

General Sherman described the horrible carnage: there were piles of dead soldiers, mangled bodies without heads and legs. "The scenes on this field would have cured anybody of war." News of Shiloh shocked the nation with its scale of violence and showed the Civil War would be long and extremely costly. A few weeks later, the capture of New Orleans would prove another northern win in the West. By that summer, the focus of the war would swing back east, as we cover in our episode on the Second Battle of Manassas.